What Happens When a SOC 2 Audit Identifies Control Exceptions?

SOC 2 audit is the process to demonstrate that the organization has implemented the right security controls to protect sensitive information. But in the process of assessment, auditors can find gaps and failures in the implementation. This is called SOC 2 Audit Exceptions. It happens when a security control doesn’t work as expected or as per the documented requirements.

The SOC 2 Audit Exceptions doesn’t always mean that the organization has failed their audit. It depends on the gravity and corrective actions taken against the issues. Knowing the process helps the businesses to better the security measures. And it also helps in keeping the effective SOC 2 compliance.

What Are Control Exceptions in a SOC 2 Audit?

Control exception occurs when there is a deviation from a defined security policy or procedure detected by auditors. Auditors go through the documents, ask questions to the employees, review evidence and test certain controls in order to determine whether it’s effective.

As an example, the company might require a user access review every quarter. If there is a missing user access review, this might be an exception detected by the auditor.

Examples of SOC 2 Audit Exceptions:

  1. failure of access management: ex-employees still have access to company systems
  2. failure of security reviews: missing scheduled user access review
  3. no evidence of security actions done
  4. delayed handling of vulnerabilities: no resolution of security vulnerabilities found
  5. lack of employee training: some employees missed mandatory training on security
  6. no backups as per documented procedures: missing required backups

What Happens After Auditors Identify Control Exceptions?

When SOC 2 Audit Exceptions are detected, they’re documented and assessed for potential impact. There is typically a 5-step process for this.

  • Auditors Document

In document form, auditors capture the control being tested, the evidence observed, and the deviation. For SOC 2 Type II audits, they document the tests performed and the results.

  • The Company Assesses Impact

Is there a significant security or operational impact? Auditors assess impact based on the control, the frequency, the potential exposure of data, and the effectiveness of other controls.

  • The Company Identifies Root Cause

Management will determine the reason for failure of the control. Is there confusion over responsibilities, a lack of monitoring, a failure to have automated reminders, etc.? The source of the problem will help prevent future SOC 2 Audit Exceptions.

  • Management Implements Corrective Actions

The organization will take steps to remediate the problem. Typical remedial steps include:

  • Updating security policies and procedures
  • Enhancing user access management
  • Automating compliance activities
  • Clear control ownership
  • More employee training
  • Regular internal reviews

Organizations should document their remedial actions taken.

  • Auditors Evaluate the Results

Auditors Assess Remediation after considering the results, impact and available evidence, then auditors will form an opinion. An issue that is resolved after a control failure does not remove the initial exception but remediation is evidence of management’s commitment to enhance security.

How Do Control Exceptions Affect the Final SOC 2 Audit Report?

The severity and impact of the SOC 2 Audit Exceptions might affect the final audit opinion. It doesn’t automatically mean that we’ll issue a qualified/adverse opinion only because you have identified the exceptions.

Audit Opinion Meaning
Unmodified Opinion All applicable requirements are met in all material respects.
Qualified Opinion A material issue exists, but its impact is not pervasive.
Adverse Opinion Material and pervasive issues prevent a positive conclusion.
Disclaimer of Opinion The auditor cannot obtain sufficient evidence to form an opinion.

The auditor considers professional judgment, available evidence, and applicable reporting requirements before determining the final opinion.

What Is the Difference Between a SOC 2 Control Exception and a Control Deficiency?

Control exception is a specific instance where a control doesn’t work as intended. Control deficiency is a general weakness in the design or implementation of a control that can lead to increased security risk. There may be multiple exceptions which indicate a control deficiency.

Knowing the difference between these terms will allow organizations to detect repeated problems, appropriately assess risk, and take proper action to improve the SOC 2 compliance program.

How Can Organizations Prevent Future SOC 2 Audit Exceptions?

Minimize recurring exceptions:

  1. Do regular internal assessments of control weaknesses in order to avoid surprises during external audits
  2. Keep documentation up-to-date, e.g. security policies, access review, audit evidence
  3. Automate compliance activities to make monitoring the controls and collecting the evidence easy
  4. Clarify the responsibilities for employees for the management and monitoring of the security controls
  5. Perform regular review of the system access and reduce unused user permissions
  6. Monitor corrective actions. Make sure that the identified issues are solved and the improvements are effective.

Conclusion

SOC 2 Audit Exceptions may not necessarily mean a failure in your audit. Rather it can point out the areas where you need to work on your security controls and improve upon them. Root Cause Analysis and corrective measures, monitoring the effectiveness of controls can help businesses avoid repeating the same issues.

Being Pro-active in achieving SOC 2 compliance can help you in improving your security practices and having robust control and increase the confidence in protecting the sensitive information. The objective is not just to complete a SOC 2 Audit, but ensure that your security controls work in the best possible way throughout the year.

FAQs

1. Does having SOC 2 Audit Exceptions mean you failed your audit? 

You haven’t necessarily failed your audit. The auditor will consider the significance, potential impact and relevance of the exceptions in forming their opinion.

2. Can you have an Unmodified Opinion with SOC 2 Exceptions? 

Yes. You can have an unmodified opinion despite the exceptions called out in the report, as long as all material requirements were fulfilled.

3. Can you fix control exceptions after you’re audited? 

Yes. You can take corrective actions after being audited. But those aren’t going to undo any original findings. You’ll need your improved controls to be effective.

4. How can your business prepare for your next SOC 2 audit? 

Perform internal assessments, keep good documentation, appoint control owners, automate evidence collection, track corrective actions.

Take a call from Expert

Moreover, if you want any other guidance relating to SOC 2 Audit Exceptions, please feel free to talk to our business advisors at 8881-069-069.

Download the E-Startup Mobile App and never miss the latest updates relevant to your business.

 

 

 

 

Leave a Comment